Bruce Lear lives in Sioux City and has been connected to Iowa’s public schools for 38 years. He taught for eleven years and represented educators as an Iowa State Education Association regional director for 27 years until retiring. He can be reached at BruceLear2419@gmail.com
We’ve all attended parties living two hours beyond when it should die. The conversation ends, the chip dip separates, there’s more empty beer cans than full. But there’s always someone trying to keep it alive.
We all know that guy. He tells another loud, obnoxious joke. As yawns drown out the music, he shouts, “Let’s play a drinking game.”
There’s a mad dash for the door. It’s time to go home.
It’s time for the Iowa legislature to end the party under the Golden Dome. It’s as moldy as that half sandwich forgotten in the car, and it’s twice as dangerous.
They’re proposing extreme legislation never mentioned in their never-ending campaigns. Did anyone hear about Bible study and chaplains for public schools? Did any candidate mention public libraries were a dire threat?
For a party that once preached small government and local control, there’s a whole lot of big government and a big batch of anti-local control proposed.
Here’s what I mean.
Senate File 138 and the companion House File 448 allows schools to offer Bible study as an elective course in social studies. When I taught literature, I often referenced the Bible since American literature is full of Biblical imagery.
I also referenced movies, other books, and current TV shows. That’s what teachers do. There’s no law against referencing the Bible or any other religious document. But apparently, that’s not enough.
They want teachers who they once claimed were “pornographers, groomers, and woke” to teach public Sunday school. The bill doesn’t mention any other religious books as part of the social studies elective. It’s not about teaching Bible as literature. This is another attempt to force-feed public school students one brand of Christian religion. I’m surprised the bill doesn’t require the Trump Bible as the study guide.
But wait, there’s more. House File 334 would allow public schools and charter schools to hire chaplains or allow them to volunteer. The bill lays out no requirements for the chaplains and does not explain their role.
Apparently, anyone who wants to be a chaplain can call themselves one. The only requirement is to pass a background check. Are parents required to be notified when their child goes to visit the chaplain?
There’s a two-pronged attack on public libraries. Senate File 235 and the companion House File 521 would remove the Iowa Code section exempting educational institutions and public libraries from obscenity laws. The strangest explanation for passing this bill came from Republican State Representative Bob Henderson at a League of Women Voter forum in Sioux City. Without evidence, he claimed, when the legislature cracked down on obscene material in public schools, public libraries were the recipients of that material.
This bill opens the door for costly lawsuits debating if a book is obscene. Local libraries already have trained librarians monitoring children’s sections. The party that screamed about parental control over schools sure doesn’t have much faith in parents monitoring what their kids check out from public libraries.
Every local library has policies allowing community members a process for objecting to a book. This bill robs communities of local control and tries to force a one size fits all approach. What may be against community standards in Sioux Center may be acceptable in Iowa City.
The second attack on public libraries is Senate File 238 and its companion House File 284. Under these bills, local libraries would become ineligible for the Enrich Iowa aid program if they are dues-paying members of a state or federal advocacy organization. State and federal organizations advocate library freedom. So, if a local library is a part of a group advocating freedom, it must be a sinister place.
What are some solutions?
The legislative session is too long. Limit it by law to three weeks. If there’s an emergency, the governor may call a special session.
Limit Iowa House members to three two-year terms. Limit state senators to two four-year terms.
Limit the governor and lieutenant governor to two four-year terms.
After the three-week session, each representative and senator must provide his/her constituents with a list of five things they did to help Iowans.
As the song says, “It’s closing time, you don’t have to go home, but you can’t stay here.”
4 Comments
Look over shoulder. We’ve crossed the redline
Thank you, Bruce for the list of woes reaped on Iowa in the last month. It’s appalling. But it has been continuous—each session since 2017.
It up sets my apple cart and makes me really upset. When my apple cart is this up set, it’s hard to pick all the apples up and put them back, especially if a bully is hovering over you. I’m reminded of the famous line from the 1976 movie Network, “I’m as mad as hell and I’m not going to take this anymore!”
It’s easy for an old man to claim having once “stood our ground.” If we examine public policy since 2017 (Trump) it’s clear the “red line” is well behind us. We must do more. Or, I don’t think Iowans will pay attention unless there are more emphatic demonstrations sufficient to drag ma and pa voter to reconsider the merits of their repetious GOP votes.
We saw yesterday and numerous times before that advocates and concerned/affected citizens crowd into the Capitol. This time I saw State Police forcibly restrain protesters. But 2000 people urging retention of “fairness” protections for a minority of citizen that we all know is vulnerable to abuse. The rightwing in Iowa is inch-by-inch encroaching on the intellectual integrity of the state and forcing public school teachers to cower under threat of dismissal for teaching historically accurate material.
My first intro (retired and linked to the real world through trusted new sources) was in the NBC NEWS podcast ‘Southlake” that traced an affluent Texas community’s response to social media posts from a party where high school students were shouting the “N” word into an iPhone with full knowledge the video would go up on a social media site. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/southlake/id1582213644?i=1000533535952
Make a plan. 2026 can’t get here fast enough. But it won’t take care of itself.
A. Clear the MAGAs out of Congress. Iowa legislature.
B. Impeachment the prick
C. Cabinet will have already inflicted on us with the inglorious consequences of generalized incompetence.
D. Iowans must do our part. Vote. And whole family.
E. We’ll replace Ernst with any willing jackass. Give Reynolds the bird. Make Rob Sand the leader of our band.
Gerald Ott Fri 28 Feb 9:44 AM
Don't Clap Too Loudly
The Iowa GOP’s super majority government trifecta has filled its members with hubris.
They smile, clap and self-congratulate as they pass laws that are tinged with hate and erode Iowa institutions such as the public school system.
I’d suggest that they not celebrate too heartily.
Slowly people will begin to reject the State of Iowa for what it represents.
Younger Iowans will choose to leave the state to live where diversity is valued, public schools are honored and environmental protection is a priority.
The professionals and skilled workers the state needs to recruit from outside the state will bypass Iowa for similar reasons.
Unlike working people who simply do the work, politicians are always concerned about their legacies.
Today’s GOP elected officials will be disappointed about what they read about themselves 10 and 20 years from now.
Their legacy will be how they took a once great state and stripped it of its decency.
Bill Bumgarner Fri 28 Feb 12:22 PM
Not from Iowa
I don’t tell people I’m from Iowa when I travel. It’s too embarrassing.
Kburr Sat 1 Mar 2:30 PM
The Avalanche Of Awfulness strategy
With so many bad bills being lobbed through the Statehouse, who can keep track of them all? I focus on the anti-conservation bills, and there are so many that it’s very hard just trying to follow those.
Sympathies to the good-cause lobbyists who are doing the best they can in a very hostile situation. If any of you happen to read this, thank you.
PrairieFan Tue 4 Mar 9:21 PM