Terry Branstad's misguided view of fighting for Iowa agriculture

Speaking to a small crowd at the Iowa State Fair yesterday, Governor Terry Branstad said he was “proud as governor to have stood up for and fought for the interests of agriculture.” You can watch the video on the Des Moines Register’s website and read highlights in O.Kay Henderson’s report for Radio Iowa or Jason Noble’s summary for the Register:

He described his defense of Beef Products Inc. and its lean finely textured beef against charges that it was unhealthy “pink slime”; his support for wind energy; his efforts to maintain the current renewable fuel standard for ethanol content in gasoline; and his opposition to California chicken cage standards that could harm Iowa egg producers.

Branstad certainly was a vocal advocate for “pink slime,” even depicting the product as some kind of superior health food. He’s eager to defend one company’s use of methods many consumers find repulsive, but I doubt the Terrace Hill chef is serving him many meals containing lean finely-textured beef.

Renewable energy advocates in Iowa would not characterize Branstad as a champion for wind. I’ve never heard of him lifting a finger to support “distributed generation” policies, which would benefit a much broader group of farmers and landowners than the large wind farms now dotting rural Iowa.

True, the governor has argued strenuously for maintaining the Renewable Fuels Standard, contradicting his usual stance against “big government regulations” and federal mandates. However, it’s debatable whether the RFS is as important to Iowa’s economy as some interest groups claim.

Branstad can pander all he wants about “the State of California with its wacky ideas,” but the lawsuit he joined on behalf of Iowa is lacking in logic and unlikely to overturn California’s egg law. It’s also ironic that a governor who claims to oppose “activist judges” is pinning his hopes on them in this case and in another lawsuit challenging a different California law.

Meanwhile, Branstad has either done nothing or actively impeded solutions on several issues that pose an enormous threat to Iowa agriculture. We’re losing world-class topsoil at an alarming rate, diminishing the future productivity of our land. Yet Branstad vetoed millions of dollars this year for Iowa watershed and land stewardship projects. Nor has he ever proposed funding the Natural Resources Trust Fund, which Iowa voters approved four years ago.

“Superweeds” resistant to the most prevalent herbicides are spreading across Iowa. Branstad has never advocated for or promoted more sustainable farming methods, which could address the weed problem more effectively than dumping more toxic chemicals on the land. Incidentally, Big Ag’s preferred approach to battling superweeds could could put a lot of Iowa vineyards and fruit growers out of business–never mind the potential risks to human health.

About the Author(s)

desmoinesdem

  • Branstad did sign the solar energy tax credit increase

    The legislature tripled the amount of money available for solar energy tax credits. That’s a good step toward distributed generation. Of course some of the demand for solar panels is for installation on hog confinements, so this is still consistent with your characterization of Branstad’s love for factory farms.

  • Re: Branstad follows the money

    Branstad follows the money.  Jack DeCoster has made big contributions to him.  So has ethanol huckster Bruce Rastetter.  So have all of the corporate ag PACs.  Small family, vegetable and organic farmers have no money.  Once again, this misguided misplaced “loyalty” to agriculture can be directly traced to political contributions.  Branstad is simply advocating for those who “butter” his bread.

    But there are hopeful signs.  More and more of our citizens are disgusted by our nitrate and Roundup and algae laced rivers and lakes.  The Des Moines Waterworks continues to beat the drum about what it costs to remove ag fertilizer and chemicals from the city’s drinking water.  The number of letters to the Des Moines Register on water quality is growing every week.  A tidal wave is coming that will overwhelm the corporate money and Branstad, and we will pass laws regulating agricultural pollution.  

Comments