Scrutiny leads to planned payback of economic development loan

After failing to deliver on its promises, a Cedar Rapids company has agreed to pay back–with interest–a $250,000 loan the Iowa Economic Development Authority awarded last year. Solid reporting by a local journalist may have made the difference between this case and the sad story from Webster City, which Bleeding Heartland discussed here.

Rick Smith reported late last week that the Cedar Rapids-based AgSugar International, now known as Vertecra, agreed “to pay back the $250,000 at 5 percent interest over a period of 30 months.”

Technology that would allegedly revolutionize cellulosic ethanol production was the promise behind AgSugar International’s $600,000 package from the Iowa Economic Development Authority and local tax incentives from the city of Cedar Rapids. The allure of high-tech jobs was powerful, as in the case of Webster City’s electric car deal gone bad. That economic development project generated tons of favorable media publicity two years ago, but few tough questions were asked about the company’s ability to follow through. Now Webster City is unlikely to recover hundreds of thousands of dollars loaned to firms whose owner recently declared bankruptcy.

I hope Vertecra sticks to the agreed schedule for paying back the AgSugar International loan. I wonder whether this deal would be happening if not for Smith’s reporting for the Cedar Rapids Gazette.

In January, Smith reported that the biotechnology machines at the center of AgSugar International’s Cedar Rapids project didn’t work. Months earlier, AgSugar executives had given up on the “eccentric, charming” inventor of the machines. They switched to a business plan for LED office light production while continuing to seek local and state economic development funding. (It probably didn’t hurt that Cedar Rapids Mayor Ron Corbett was an investor in a different small company owned by senior executives at AgSugar/Vertecra. )

About two weeks after the Cedar Rapids Gazette published these reports, Iowa Economic Development Authority met with Vertecra officials to discuss the project. Ongoing scrutiny prompted the agency to order Vertecra in April “to return a $250,000 state grant and not to use other public aid awarded to it.” That demand led to the negotiated settlement approved last week.

I encourage you to click through and read all of Smith’s reporting on the AgSugar debacle. We need more journalism like this in Iowa–though I don’t know where it’s going to come from in the age of endless newsroom budget cuts.

About the Author(s)

desmoinesdem

  • Good report

    It is truly sad that we don’t have more hardline reporting out there.  It is easier for people to just read a slanted Tweet for free or a hyper-ideological blog for people to get their news.  There has to be a market for true journalism and “traditional” news sources.

    People like John Deeth made fun of people like David Broder (with some justification) about David’s attempts to call for moderation and attempts to establish seemingly non-ideological facts in his columns.  I know Broder and people like him were a relic in a sense, but I enjoy that kind of journalistic “integrity” as I see it.  Some people just consider that journalism without a spine, but I call it integrity.

    I hope these incentive programs don’t go by the waste side.  Secretary Chu, Barack Obama and thousands of other political figures were doing the right thing with the concept behind a Solyndra.  I find the principles behind these programs to be more valuable to society than the SNAP program for example, but that’s just my personal view.  I understand a lot of public programs are more practical and cheaper in nature.  

    I simply don’t think its realistic to say that people are going to leverage one hundred percent private capital in rural communities to fund projects.  I admire Jeff Flake’s  (for example) constant attempts to say that the private sector can and should completely fund projects, but a guy like Flake is more of a Libertarian type who doesn’t really worry about full employment.  

    • ag motorsports.......

      I look forward to the day we do NOT have the USDA giving out hundreds of thousands of dollars to new tractor pull museums in way out of the way small towns…I guess with today’s news we are nowhere close to that.

Comments