Sometimes it’s amazing how many lies and misleading statements Republicans can fit into one 30-second television commercial:
This statement from Barack Obama’s spokesman, Bill Burton, is right on:
“Despite being discredited over and over again by numerous news organizations, the McCain campaign continues to repeat the lie that Sarah Palin stopped the Bridge to Nowhere. John McCain has voted with George Bush 90% of the time and he and Sarah Palin will continue Bush’s economic policies, his health care policy, his education policy, his energy policy, and his foreign policy. McCain and Palin will say or do anything to make people believe that they will change something besides the person sitting in the Oval Office. That’s the kind of politics people are tired of, and it’s anything but change,” said Obama campaign spokesman Bill Burton.
The Obama campaign has also released an extensive fact check debunking almost every claim this ad makes. You can read it here:
http://blogs.creativeloafing.c…
It shows that contrary to the impression the commercial gives viewers:
-Senator McCain supported almost the entire George Bush agenda
-McCain voted for plenty of earmarks
-Governor Palin was originally for the Bridge to Nowhere
-Palin has been very close to the oil industry
and much more.
Regrettably, Obama did not do enough this summer to brand McCain as Bush’s third term as well as a liar who will say anything to win. Better late than never, though.
UPDATE: Excellent rapid response from the Obama campaign:
Hits McCain on the Washington lobbyists running his campaign and on voting with Bush more than 90 percent of the time. Hits Palin on being for the Bridge to Nowhere before she was against it. Great closer:
“Politicians lying about their records–you don’t call that ‘maverick.’ You call it more of the same.”
Obama simply cannot allow McCain to brand himself as the reform candidate who will bring change to Washington. He would bring more of the same failed Bush policies and corruption.
6 Comments
News
I think Obama needs to do something to get into the news. It has been non-stop about Palin for the last week.
lorih Mon 8 Sep 4:30 PM
agenda-setting
The media don’t tell people what to think, but they tell them what to think about.
I agree with you. I am hoping he will make some big news.
I heard rumors about Colin Powell and other retired generals endorsing him, but I will believe that when I see it. Powell has no credibility with me, but that would be a big deal.
desmoinesdem Mon 8 Sep 6:12 PM
New Obama response ad
You’re going to need to update your post…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…
nolan Mon 8 Sep 4:58 PM
thanks
Done!
desmoinesdem Mon 8 Sep 6:07 PM
This is a trap
I don’t think we’re going to get anywhere by spending time refuting the fine points of McCain’s ads, even if they’re outright lies.
Attempting to do so makes us look nit-picky, especially to people who are still on the fence. We have to be careful to refute only the meat of their arguments, not the details.
Let me illustrate:
“I sold the plane on e-bay.” This got loud cheers and applause from the crowd. It was a classy moment for Palin. It made her the “cool kid”.
Our response? “Well, she didn’t really sell her plane on e-bay, actually it was sold at auction..yadda, yadda…”
Who looks worse, them for stretching the truth? or us for tattling? Which one of us has the taped glasses with the pocket protector? We’re jumping on some of these issues like a heat-seeking missile seeks a flare.
How about Palin’s flip/flop on the bridge to nowhere? That has more substance, but if our critique of the bridge issue is nested between the critique of the e-bay sale and some other trivial point, it’s more easily dismissed.
I think that the Republicans are goading us into attacking John McCain’s near-unassailable trait–his character.
One way to refute this, is to find the meat in our own arguments and get some substance into this race. Then let McCain/Palin chase us for a while. Another way is to attack the Republican Party itself, rather than its figureheads. The GOP has chosen a presidential candidate whom it’s despised, and one who’s despised it. They’re a party that no longer knows itself. The party that wants government to “leave us alone” is the one that taps our phone lines.
The party is the weakest link.
johnnyschad Mon 8 Sep 6:05 PM
the Obama response ad is good
Doesn’t wade into the weeds, just makes clear that McCain is like Bush, supports Bush policies and has Washington lobbyists running his campaign. Palin is also lying about her record, as the great shot of her with the “Nowhere” t-shirt reveals.
Republicans are masters of the misleading statement that is technically not a lie. In her convention speech, I believe Palin said of the plane, “I put it on eBay.” And she did put it on eBay. But it did not sell on eBay, so she sold it later for a $500K loss. The way she phrased it was technically not a lie, but it would create a false impression in people’s minds.
desmoinesdem Mon 8 Sep 6:10 PM