The Boston Globe has an article by Charlie Savage – the journalist whose investigation first brought President Bush's use of signing statements to light – about the various positions by Democratic and Republican candidates on executive powers. Here are a few of the most direct answers to critically important questions that the tenure of the Bush administration has raised to date.
4. Under what circumstances, if any, would you sign a bill into law but also issue a signing statement reserving a constitutional right to bypass the law?
Never. If I thought it was unconstitutional, I would turn to the Courts, which is what our founding fathers expected and provided for in cases of Executive-Congressional differences.
5. Does the Constitution permit a president to detain US citizens without charges as unlawful enemy combatants?
No.
6. Does executive privilege cover testimony or documents about decision-making within the executive branch not involving confidential advice communicated to the president himself?
No.
What's remarkable, I think, is that Senator Dodd's dedication to upholding the Constitution and the balance of powers requires this sort of answer to these sorts of questions, though you won't see the GOP candidates or top Republican talking heads giving the same consideration to these issues. Standing up for the rule of law makes us more safe at home. We need a President who will stand up for these issues, even if it means rolling back some of the powers and practices used by the Bush administration in contravention to the Constitution and at the expense of the balance of powers between the executive, legislative, and judiciary branch.
You can read Senator Dodd's full response to the Globe's questionnaire here.
2 Comments
Dodd's answers were crystal clear
Dodd’s answers were crystal clear and direct. This has been his central theme, and it shows. Obama’s answers weren’t bad either, but Edwards and Clinton were hedging their bets.
corncam Sun 23 Dec 2:18 PM
I have a lot of respect for Dodd
for raising the profile of this issue all year.
It’s amazing to me that the other sitting senators running for president have not shown as much leadership.
desmoinesdem Sun 23 Dec 5:05 PM